Correcting errors in filed tax returns
When can errors be corrected in a later return, when is an amendment needed, and what role does voluntary disclosure play?
A client discovers an error in a tax return filed several months ago. Perhaps an expense was overlooked, income was reported incorrectly, or the wrong figures were used. Does the original return need to be amended, or can the mistake be corrected in a later return?
The answer depends on the type of error, its tax effect and when it was discovered.
Can the error be corrected in the next return?
Section 113A of the Tax Administration Act 1994 (TAA) allows certain errors in income tax, goods and services tax (GST) and fringe benefit tax (FBT) returns to be corrected in the next return due after the error is discovered.
According to Inland Revenue's guidance, this option is available where the total tax discrepancy arising from errors in a return is:
- $1,000 or less, or
- No more than the lower of $10,000 and 2% of the taxpayer's annual gross income (for income tax or FBT), or 2% of GST output tax for the relevant return period (for GST).
The second threshold cannot be used mainly to delay paying tax.
Consider a company that discovers it omitted $2,500 of taxable income from its previous income tax return. At the 28% company tax rate, the additional tax is $700. Assuming the other requirements of section 113A are met, the company can correct the error in its next income tax return without requesting an amendment to the original assessment.
Practitioners should calculate the tax effect of all errors identified in the return before deciding whether the next-return correction option is available. The relevant figure is the total tax discrepancy, not the amount of income or expenses incorrectly reported.
Practitioners should also establish when the error was identified and confirmed. Inland Revenue accepts that taxpayers may need time to investigate a potential error before making a correction in the next return due.
Taxpayers do not need to notify Inland Revenue separately of a correction made under section 113A, but they should retain records explaining the error and supporting the adjustment.
What if the error cannot be corrected in the next return?
Where section 113A does not apply and no other correction provision is available, an amendment to the original assessment may be necessary.
Section 113 of the TAA gives the Commissioner discretion to amend assessments to ensure their correctness. Inland Revenue's SPS 20/03: Requests to amend assessments explains how amendment requests are considered.
Inland Revenue generally expects taxpayers to use an available self-correction mechanism rather than request a discretionary amendment under section 113. However, where an error has resulted in an underpayment of tax, practitioners should also consider whether a voluntary disclosure is appropriate, as a qualifying disclosure may result in a reduction in shortfall penalties.
Some amendments can be requested through myIR. Practitioners should identify the affected period, explain what went wrong and provide the corrected figures and supporting information.
Where Inland Revenue is satisfied that an amendment will produce a correct assessment, it will generally make the adjustment unless there is a valid reason not to do so. The Commissioner must exercise this discretion to amend reasonably, taking into account relevant statutory requirements and the circumstances of the request.
GST errors may need a different approach
Under section 20(3) of the Goods and Services Tax Act 1985, a previously omitted input tax deduction can generally be claimed in a later taxable period if that period begins on or before the second anniversary of the earlier of the date payment was made for the supply or taxable supply information was issued.
A deduction may also be claimed outside that period where the failure to claim arose from an inability to obtain taxable supply information, a dispute over the amount payable for the supply, a mistaken understanding that the supply was not taxable, or a clear mistake or simple oversight.
Adjustments arising from supply correction information are generally included in the GST return for the period in which that information is provided or received, subject to applicable statutory time limits.
What if the client wants to change a tax position?
Not every proposed correction involves a mistake. For example, a client may wish to revisit a tax treatment deliberately adopted when filing, rather than correct an overlooked expense or an incorrect figure.
Where a taxpayer wants to change a previously adopted tax position, the formal disputes process may be required. This generally involves submitting a notice of proposed adjustment (NOPA) within the applicable statutory timeframe.
The Commissioner has broad discretion under section 113, including in some circumstances to amend an otherwise correct assessment. However, when exercising that discretion, Inland Revenue may consider whether the request is an attempt to circumvent the statutory disputes process or revisit a tax position simply because the taxpayer regrets their original choice.
Before making a correction
Practitioners should confirm the affected return, establish when the error was discovered and calculate its tax effect.
A qualifying full voluntary disclosure made before notification of a pending tax audit or investigation can reduce shortfall penalties by 100% for not taking reasonable care or taking an unacceptable tax position or taking an unacceptable interpretation, and by 75% for gross carelessness, taking an abusive tax position or evasion. Other reductions, including for previous behaviour, may also apply.
A voluntary disclosure does not remove the underlying tax liability, and use-of-money interest may still apply.