Limited assurance isn’t light assurance
Holding at limited assurance gives the market time to build capability. It is not a signal to stop.
Earlier this month, CA ANZ lodged its submission to Treasury's consultation on improving the efficiency of climate-related financial disclosures. One of our key recommendations was to maintain limited assurance at this stage, rather than set a fixed date for the transition to reasonable assurance.
The 2026/27 Federal Budget also proposed raising the thresholds for large proprietary companies. Taken together, these proposals may lead some to conclude that the pressure has eased. That is not the case.
Timing, not ambition
Australia is among the first jurisdictions to apply both a reporting standard aligned with IFRS S2 Climate-related disclosures and an assurance standard aligned with ISSA 5000 General Requirements for Sustainability Assurance Engagements. No major jurisdiction yet requires reasonable assurance in practice and the European Union has recently removed its planned transition to reasonable. Moving first would mean resolving implementation issues without the benefit of precedent.
Maintaining limited assurance allows reporting and assurance practices to mature and lets Australia learn from international experience before making a decision that would be difficult to reverse. Any future move to reasonable assurance should be market-led and supported by evidence that the benefits to users outweigh the costs. It is not a step back from assurance requirements.
Limited, but not light
For many, the frame of reference for limited assurance is a half-year review of financial statements. By then, the auditor has completed the full-year audit and has an established understanding of the entity, its systems and controls, which provides a strong foundation for targeted enquiries and review procedures.
Standalone limited assurance under ASSA 5000 has no such foundation. Practitioners need to understand the climate systems, data and judgements from the ground up. It is also a considerable step up from the voluntary sustainability assurance engagements many firms previously performed under ASAE 3000 Assurance Engagements Other than Audits or Reviews of Historical Financial Information.
First-wave reporting entities consistently told us the assurance work was more extensive than they expected. Part of that is an expectation gap, with preparers and practitioners applying new standards at the same time for the first time.
Maintaining limited assurance does not make the work smaller and it does not lower the bar.
What the first year tells us
The State of the Market report, prepared by Purpose Bureau with the collaboration of CA ANZ and Monash Business School, analysed 154 ASX-listed Group 1 reporters. The Big Four assured 145 of them, and almost without exception the assurer was also the financial statement auditor.
Some reporters went further than required. Almost one in three extended assurance beyond the year-one minimum, and 15 obtained reasonable assurance over Scope 1 and 2 emissions, typically where they had obtained that level of assurance before. It is encouraging to see leaders go further. But these are among Australia's largest listed companies, and their choices are not necessarily indicative of the broader population.
Beyond Group 1
Group 2 entities’ first reporting periods began on or after 1 July 2026, and Group 3 follows from 1 July 2027. Group 3 is the largest cohort by number. Many of these entities are audited by mid-sized and smaller firms, which may not have the same depth of specialist expertise as the largest firms.
If the Group 1 pattern continues, existing financial statement audit relationships will be a natural starting point. However, the law does not require it. A company's sustainability report does not have to be assured by its financial statement auditor (although registrable superannuation entities are an exception).
Capability takes time
Research by CA ANZ, the University of Sydney, Monash and ANU found around 300 assurance firms servicing the sustainability assurance market. A consistent message from the first cycle is that everything took longer than expected, for reporting entities and assurance practitioners alike. Smaller firms rarely have spare capacity, so capability has to be built alongside the day job.
However it is important to remember that practitioners do not need to become climate scientists. ASSA 5000 and APES 110 recognise the use of experts where specialist knowledge is needed. The lead practitioner determines when that input is required, evaluates the expert and their work and takes responsibility for the conclusion. The core skills are assurance skills, and they are transferable: understanding the entity, assessing risk, testing controls, gathering evidence and applying professional judgement.
Key messages for assurance practitioners
Three messages stand out.
First, limited assurance is not light. It is already a substantial engagement, and maintaining it does not lower the bar. If the market shows it needs reasonable assurance in future, the capability firms build now will be the foundation for it.
Second, early engagement with clients makes a significant difference. Talking now with entities in Groups 2 and 3 about their data, their documentation and what assurance will involve helps close the expectation gap for them before it opens.
Third, capability is best built as a firm. Team-based learning, combined with a clear view of where experts will be needed, will hold up better than individuals upskilling in isolation.
Sustainability assurance
For a clear picture of where things stand, CA ANZ's Current sustainability assurance landscape brings together the key requirements in one place: ASSA 5000, the phasing of assurance under ASSA 5010, who can provide assurance and the ethics, independence and quality management requirements that apply in Australia and New Zealand.
Read more